Loading... Please wait...
  • Toppings will vary by flavor, however you can add confetti or sprinkles, too!
  • Let us box your CUTS® together so you can plate them individually or on a platter.
  • With a Bunch O' CUTS, you get 5 for the price of 4! Available for local pick-up only. Choose individual boxes to hand out as gifts, favors, or convenient serving.
  • TOP SELLER ALERT: this flavor has been our best seller for over 39 years! Two layers of moist Yellow cake filled with our (non-alcoholic) Rum custard, layered with fresh strawberry slices, and topped with Lisa's Italian whipped cream. ADD $1.00.
  • Pucker-up, lemon lovers! Two layers of moist Yellow cake filled with zesty (non-alcoholic) Limoncello custard and topped with Lisa's Italian whipped cream.
  • A 39-year classic: two layers of moist Chocolate cake filled with signature Chocolate (non-alcoholic) Rum custard and topped with Lisa's Italian whipped cream.
  • Our top selling chocolate flavor featuring the perfect chocolate/vanilla blend: two layers of moist Chocolate cake filled with French Vanilla custard studded with mini, gourmet chocolate chips and topped with our signature whipped cream.
  • Our unique, Italian version of an American favorite. Small bits of carrot with the necessary spices make this an extra moist spice cake. No nuts, no raisins, no coconut, just our French Vanilla custard.

Bunch O' CUTS (Local Pick-Up)

Local pick-up only.

    CUTS® are a perfect treat for every ocassion. Choose an assortment of 5 different flavors Premium flavors are $1.00 extra (each).

    Cake CUTS® are two layers of cake filled with decadent Italian custard and topped with Lisa's signature Italian whipped cream. Each cake CUT is individually boxed and equivalent to 2.5 standard cupcakes in weight and serves 1-2 people.  Tax included in cost. We accept same day orders (but flavors may be subject to availability). Please order a minimum of 48 hours in advance to guarantee your flavors.


    Write your own product review

    Showing reviews 1-10 of 14 | Next

    1. Outstanding  star rating

      Posted by Mike on 3rd Mar 2019

      As always … The best ...

    2. love it  star rating

      Posted by reneta on 23rd Jun 2016

      Love the packaging and i could give it away for my friends. I love the chocolate rum. Just ordered another one for my dinner this friday with my friends. I will order my next birthday cake from them this year.

    3. best reaction to desert from my lunch guests  star rating

      Posted by Unknown on 10th Mar 2016

      I ordered the cuts in the individual boxes in a variety of favors. 1st it is great to be pre cut when serving multiple guests.
      2. It tastes so yummy. 3. I served on a tray & let the guest chose the flavor & the reaction was so awesome everybody became a little kid choosing their flavor.
      They were hit of party.

    4. Superb  star rating

      Posted by Shelby on 19th Jan 2016

      I took advantage of the buy 4 get 1 free CUTS deal and tried several different flavors, all of which were amazing but my absolute fave was the strawberry rum. The smooth, rich sweetness of the custard was perfectly complimented by the tartness of the strawberries and the ratio of filling to cake was just right. Every bite was a mouthgasm and definitely worthy of slightly-inappropriate-made-up-adjectives. Good thing I don't live too close to the shop, otherwise wiggling into my skinny jeans would quickly become a problem.

    5. BEST DESSERT EVER!!!!  star rating

      Posted by Marcia Hill on 6th Dec 2015

      There are not enough superlatives to describe Lisa's Rum Cake. From the first contact, to private emails to be sure all was correct, to the finished product and pickup. All ran smoothly. And the Rum Cake cake was a real hit in our family. We got the Cake Cuts, a selection of 5 different flavors. Each flavor was a hit. Although our favorite was the Strawberry. Even the cake paper was scraped for the last drop! Thanks to Lisa and her staff!

    6. Lovely cakes. Tasty.  star rating

      Posted by Bojangles McJungleson on 6th Oct 2015

      What I said in the title. They're very good. We got the most rum flavor out of the strawberry, and maybe it was just my aging taste buds but I couldn't taste the flavor in the others. Would be curious to try the other flavors to see if we can get more balance in the rummy.

      9/10 would rum cake again

    7. The Best!!!!  star rating

      Posted by Shana D. on 9th Jun 2015

      Every cut was amazing!!! I am a fan of the carrot cake!!! Delicious!!!

    8. First time buyer  star rating

      Posted by Maggie on 29th Apr 2015

      Made my first purchase. Got the five cuts. My favorites were both filled with the rum custard...loved the chocolate rum and loved , loved, LOVED the Strawberry rum cake.

      Will be back for more.

    9. Perfect way to try more flavors  star rating

      Posted by Ann P on 8th Mar 2015

      These are great for gifts and also for experiencing all of the flavors. we have not tasted a cake we have not liked.

    10. GREAT CUTS!  star rating

      Posted by Bobbie Jo Evans on 4th Nov 2014

      It is nice to be able to try several different flavors! Very moist and fresh. Will most definitely order those again.

    Showing reviews 1-10 of 14 | Next

    Sign up for our newsletter

    View Cart Go To Checkout