Loading... Please wait...
  • Choose from four original Cathy's Rum Cake® flavors and we'll decorate it with fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate!
  • Original Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
  • Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
  • Chocolate Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Chocolate cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
  • Rum Marble: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with one layer of signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard and one layer of Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
  • Image 6

Classic Cathy's Rum Cake®

$55.00
Availability:
In-Store Pick-Up Only
Qty

    Growing up in her mother's bakery, Lisa has made thousands of cakes over the years. To pay homage to her roots, she's chosen four orignal Cathy's Rum Cake® flavors to feature with the classic Cathy's Rum Cake® decor. Celebrate any ocassion with this time honored tradition!

     

    (The quantity of strawberries and shaved chocolate included will vary by cake size. Available for in-store pick-up only.)

    Write your own product review

    1. Best Cake Ever!  star rating

      Posted by Susan K Miller on 3rd May 2016

      We always enjoy Lisa'a Rum Cake, but the classic rum cake, especially with fresh strawberries added to the filling is the very best! Thanks for making it so delicious every time.

    2. fantastic  star rating

      Posted by Gail Quirin on 6th Dec 2015

      The classic rum cake was the unexpected highlight of our celebration! It was absolutely heavenly - rich, moist, heavy - exactly the way an event cake should be. Lisa's will be a new tradition and, no doubt, a highly anticipated part of our wedding anniversary!

    3. Exactly What We Were Looking For  star rating

      Posted by Amber on 4th Oct 2015

      My boss was a big fan of Cathy's Rum Cake and I found this classic when looking for his birthday cake. There were a couple of obvious differences, he told me the original Cathy's Rum Cake was not as fluffy, more dense and grainy and the frosting was lighter, more like whipped cream. However, the flavor of the Classic Cathy's Rum Cake offered by Lisa's Rum Cake was exactly what he remembered. He loved it so much he had two pieces.
      If you were a fan of the original Cathy's Rum Cake, you can't go wrong with this cake.

    4. A True Classic!  star rating

      Posted by Brenda on 23rd Sep 2015

      We used to order all our special cakes from Cathy's Rum Cake and were so sad to see them close the stores. I found Lisa's Rum Cake on the internet and learned she was Cathy's daughter and was hoping she used her Mom's recipes. I saw the "Classic Cathy's Rum Cake" advertised and decided to order one for my sister's birthday. It was so yummy and just as I remembered it!!! I love the original with the rum custard filling and agree with the gentleman that boxed the cake for me that serving it at room temperature enhances the flavors! I will definitely be ordering more and maybe I'll get adventurous and try a new flavor!

    Sign up for our newsletter

    View Cart Go To Checkout