Loading... Please wait...
  • Image 1

Pumpkin Spice

In-Store Only

    Moist Yellow cake layers separated by our seasonal Pumpkin Spice custard.

    Write your own product review

    1. Best of the Best Ever  star rating

      Posted by Verne on 9th Dec 2014

      My family looks forward to each time I say I'm bringing a Pumpkin Spice cake from Lisa's Rum Cakes. I've brought others that they loved, but for some reason they just go nuts over this one! Of course, it's my favorite, too, so I don't mind at all if a birthday girl/boy asks for it for their special day (I know I ask for it on mine!)

    2. Lisa's Rum Cake lived up to its reputation !  star rating

      Posted by Norma Jean on 6th Oct 2014

      The cake I purchased was for my brother's birthday, and was for dessert after lunch (4 people). I ordered the six-inch cake, and was a bit apprehensive about the size, but I need not have worried. The cake was a perfect size, beautifully decorated; we had plenty for all of us to get a good-size-slice, and we even shared it with the owner of the restaurant, who loved it. I got the pumpkin spice cake and all I can say is that it was DELICIOUS.

    3. Best Cake of 2013  star rating

      Posted by Verne on 7th Dec 2013

      My family was so impressed with this cake they wanted 2nds at our Thanksgiving dinner. My niece took a piece home and ate two bites a day until it was gone and she still talks about how great it was. I'll definitely get this cake again.

    4. Boo Baby Shower  star rating

      Posted by Dawn on 6th Nov 2013

      It looked great, very cute and tasted wonderful.

    5. A delicious addition to a special occasion  star rating

      Posted by Unknown on 16th Dec 2012

      Our cake was moist and delicious and the filling was perfect with just the right amount of spice.

    6. Pumpkin Spice Cake Disappears at Party within Seconds  star rating

      Posted by Gayle Schmidt on 29th Nov 2012

      The cake was literally inhaled within minutes of its presentation.
      The raves were incredible. You saw the cake literally disappear
      right before your eyes. Everyone loved it and kept coming back for another piece. It was the hit of the Thanksgiving Feast!

    7. Grat Flavored cake  star rating

      Posted by William. M. Merrick on 17th Nov 2012

      In appreciation of the EXCELLENT care I recieved from the Phoenix VA Hospital, I gave a pumpkin flavored cake to warfarin clinic. In the words of one of the clinic's nurse - "It was a GREAT cake and never have I enjoyed such a cake".

      What more can one say!

    8. Very Good!  star rating

      Posted by Very Good! on 13th Nov 2012

      The pumpkin spice cake is really moist and tasty. I thought this was a rum cake but it is not. Still tasted good though!

    9. The Best!  star rating

      Posted by Joe on 19th Oct 2012

      I ordered the seasonal pumpkin spice cake and it was phenomenal! Extremely moist and the pumpkin filling was tasty without being overpowering. Thank you Lisa for doing a super job carrying on the family tradition.

    Sign up for our newsletter

    View Cart Go To Checkout