Choose from four original Cathy's Rum Cake® flavors and we'll decorate it with fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate! Original Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream. Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream. Chocolate Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Chocolate cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream. Rum Marble: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with one layer of signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard and one layer of Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream. Classic Cathy's Rum Cake®
Choose from four original Cathy's Rum Cake® flavors and we'll decorate it with fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate!
Original Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
Chocolate Chocolate Rum: three moist layers of Chocolate cake filled with signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
Rum Marble: three moist layers of Yellow cake filled with one layer of signature Italian (non-alcoholic) Rum custard and one layer of Chocolate Rum custard, frosted in Italian whipped cream.
Classic Cathy's Rum Cake®

Classic Cathy's Rum Cake®

$79.00
( 8 Reviews )

Having grown up in her mother's bakery, this cake pays homage to Lisa's roots. Choose from top-selling Cathy's Rum Cake® flavors to feature with the classic Cathy's Rum Cake® decor. Celebrate any occasion with this time honored traditions.

 (The quantity of strawberries and shaved chocolate included will vary by cake size. Available for in-store pick-up only.)

For freshness, we strongly recommend picking this cake up the day of or day prior to serving. 

Current stock:
Writing Color None Selected
Ribbon Color #1 None Selected
Ribbon Color #2 None Selected
Edible Glitter?
Edible Confetti (multi-color)
Picking up TODAY, TOMORROW, or NEXT BUSINESS DAY (WITHIN 3 BUSINESS DAYS • closed Sundays/holidays)? *
Add to Wishlist
Reviews

8 Reviews

5/5
Teresa Brown 18th Feb 2026

10” Strawberry Rum Cake

From-1989 to 2026 my favorite way to celebrate 36 years of marriage is with your incredible Strawberry Rum. Cake!! Thanks for this wonderful cake!! Teresa Brown

5/5
Kim Gulsvig 4th Jan 2022

Parent's 60th Anniversary with a Cathy's Rum Cake

Thank you for making my parent's 60th anniversary celebration memorable with the always delicious Cathy's Rum Cake. Rave reviews were shared and nary a piece of cake was left! Thank you Lisa!

Show more dropdown_arrow

Add a Review


Related Products