Peanut Butter & Chocolate

$79.00
( 5 Reviews )

A Cathy's Rum Cake® signature flavor! This decadent cake is handcrafted with moist chocolate cake layers, filled with creamy peanut butter and chocolate custard, frosted with our signature Italian whipped cream. If you love peanut butter, this is the flavor for you!

Current stock:

Writing Color None Selected
Ribbon Color #1 None Selected
Ribbon Color #2 None Selected
Edible Glitter?
Edible Confetti (multi-color)
Picking up TODAY, TOMORROW, or NEXT BUSINESS DAY (WITHIN 3 BUSINESS DAYS • closed Sundays/holidays)? *

5 Reviews

5/5
Richard Lauro 17th Aug 2026

One of the BEST cakes I have ever eaten

The peanut butter and chocolate cake is the best cake I have ever eaten. Rich, incredibly moist, with that signature Italian cream frosting making the chocolate-peanut butter combo pure perfection. My family orders this at least twice a year — it’s become a tradition, and everyone requests it by name. You can tell real care goes into every cake. Five stars, and I’ll be ordering again soon!

5/5
Jennifer Boyle 5th Dec 2020

Peanut Butter & Chocolate added Bananas

Amazing as all their cakes. We customized it by adding bananas in the filling. The combination was wonderful. My peanut butter lover approved.

Add a Review